As a landlord, one of the most frustrating and challenging situations you may encounter is dealing with a tenant who damages or destroys your property. Property damage can be financially and emotionally draining, whether due to negligence, intentional acts, or unforeseen circumstances. It also becomes very hard to manage your rental property effectively and how you want.

However, handling these situations calmly and strategically is crucial to minimize losses and protect your rights as a landlord.

In this comprehensive guide, I will discuss what steps you should take if a tenant destroys your property and how to navigate the legal and practical aspects.

Let’s get started.

Understanding tenant damage

Broken windows, vandalism, disaster, damage

Before diving into the steps to take when a tenant damages your property, it’s essential to understand the types of damage and the reasons behind them. Tenant damage can range from accidental spills and normal wear and tear to intentional vandalism or neglect.

Common examples of property damage by tenants include:

  1. Accidental damage: This includes broken windows, spills on carpets, or holes in walls caused by mishaps or negligence.
  2. Intentional damage: Deliberate acts of vandalism, such as punching holes in walls, graffiti, or destroying fixtures and appliances.
  3. Neglect: Failure to report or address maintenance issues promptly, leading to further deterioration of the property.
  4. Unauthorized alterations: Modifications made to the property without landlord approval, such as painting walls or installing fixtures.

Need a property management contractor?

Contact us →

As a side note, if you find a great tenant during the screening process, you won’t have to worry about securing damaged amenities. So, be aware and put your highest efforts into the tenant screening process next time.

Related: What is a good return (ROI) on a rental property?

Assessing the damage

Real estate property appraisal

The first step when dealing with tenant damage is to assess the extent of damage done to your property. Thoroughly inspect the premises to document all visible damage, taking photographs or videos as evidence.

These documents will help you to get accurate compensation or pursue legal action against the tenant. 

Additionally, consider obtaining estimates from contractors or repair professionals to determine the cost of repairs or replacements.

Related: How long does an apartment inspection take?

Reviewing the lease agreement

Next, review the lease agreement signed with the tenant to understand the rights and obligations of both parties regarding property damage.

Sell your house in 10 days in Rhode Island
For more details, please visit sell your house in 10 days →

Lease agreements typically include clauses related to tenant responsibilities, maintenance duties, and procedures for addressing damage.

Pay close attention to clauses related to security deposits, liability for repairs, and termination of the lease in case of significant damage.

Read also: What to do if the tenant doesn’t pay rent? (options for landlords)

Notifying the tenant

Sad annoyed man reading the eviction notice

Once you’ve assessed the damage and reviewed the lease agreement, it’s time to notify the tenant of the situation. 

Contact the tenant in writing, providing detailed documentation of the damage observed and any relevant clauses from the lease agreement. Clearly outline the steps the tenant needs to take to rectify the situation, including deadlines for repairs or reimbursement.

Read also: Pros and cons of hiring a property management company.

Demanding compensation

If the damage requires professional repairs or replacements, you may demand compensation from the tenant to cover the costs.

In your written notice to the tenant, include an itemized list of damages and the corresponding repair costs

Depending on the lease terms and jurisdiction, you can subtract repair costs from the security deposit or take legal action to recover additional expenses. Sometimes, security deposits may not cover all types of damages. In this case, the tenant needs to bring extra money to the table.

Read also: What does a property management company do?

Negotiating a resolution

Property maintenance contractor calling in your door

Sometimes, it’s possible to negotiate a resolution without resorting to legal action. Communicate openly with the tenant to discuss potential solutions, such as a payment plan for damages or voluntary surrender of the lease agreement.

Keep records of all communication and agreements reached during the negotiation process.

Read also: How to clean a rental property before showing it to tenants?

Legal recourse

Courtroom Witness

If the tenant refuses to cooperate or disputes liability for the damage, you may need to pursue legal recourse to protect your interests.

Consult an attorney to understand your options. Depending on the circumstances, you may file a lawsuit against the tenant for breach of lease or property damage or seek an eviction if the damage is severe.

Read also: Renting vs. Selling your home


Dealing with a tenant who destroys property is a complex and stressful experience for private landlords. However, by following the steps outlined in this guide and seeking appropriate legal advice, you can effectively navigate these situations and protect your property rights.

Remember to document all communication, assess damage thoroughly, and act promptly to minimize losses and ensure a fair resolution. 

With patience, diligence, and adherence to the law, you can address tenant damage while preserving the integrity of your rental property business.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This